Metal Roof To Asphalt Shingle Transition – When it comes to roofing, few decisions have a bigger impact on your home’s protection, appearance, and long-term value than the type of roof you choose. While many homeowners upgrade from asphalt shingles to metal roofing for durability, there are also cases where the opposite happens—homeowners transition from metal roofing back to asphalt shingles. This change might seem counterintuitive, but it often makes sense depending on budget, maintenance needs, aesthetics, or local climate conditions.
This article explores why some homeowners make the switch, the challenges involved in replacing metal with shingles, the steps of the installation process, and what you should consider before undertaking this roofing transition.
Why Switch from Metal to Asphalt Shingles?
Metal roofing is known for its durability, fire resistance, and longevity, sometimes lasting 40–70 years. However, asphalt shingles still remain the most popular roofing material in North America. Here are several reasons homeowners might choose to replace a metal roof with asphalt shingles:
Cost Considerations
Metal roofing is significantly more expensive than asphalt shingles. If a homeowner is on a tighter budget or preparing to sell a house, replacing the roof with asphalt shingles can lower costs while still providing adequate protection.
Aesthetic Preferences
While modern metal roofs come in many colors and styles, some homeowners prefer the traditional look of asphalt shingles, especially in suburban neighborhoods where shingle roofs dominate.
Noise Reduction
Rain, hail, or falling debris can sound louder on a metal roof, especially if it lacks proper insulation. Asphalt shingles, being thicker and softer, naturally dampen sound.
Ease of Repairs
Repairing a small section of asphalt shingles is usually easier and cheaper than repairing or replacing damaged metal panels. For homeowners concerned about long-term maintenance, shingles can be more practical.
Local HOA or Building Codes
Some homeowner associations (HOAs) or neighborhoods have restrictions against metal roofing, pushing homeowners toward asphalt shingles for compliance.
Challenges in Transitioning from Metal to Asphalt Shingles
Switching from a metal roof to asphalt shingles is not always straightforward. Several challenges may arise:
Roof Decking Condition
Metal roofs can sometimes be installed over old shingles, but asphalt shingles typically require a solid and even roof deck. If the decking under the metal has deteriorated, it will need repair or replacement before new shingles can be installed.
Removal of Metal Panels
Metal panels are heavy, large, and sometimes screwed down with thousands of fasteners. Removing them is labor-intensive and requires careful handling to avoid damage to the roof structure.
Underlayment Requirements
Asphalt shingles need specific underlayment materials (such as felt or synthetic membranes) that may not be present under a metal roof. This step adds additional time and cost.
Weight Differences
Metal roofs are lightweight compared to shingles. Adding asphalt shingles increases roof load. The underlying structure must be strong enough to support the additional weight safely.
Flashing and Ventilation Adjustments
Metal roof systems use different flashing and ventilation designs. When converting to shingles, contractors often need to replace flashing around chimneys, skylights, and vents, as well as ensure proper attic ventilation.
The Step-by-Step Transition Process
Here is how the transition from a metal roof to asphalt shingles typically unfolds:
Step 1: Roof Inspection
A professional roofer will inspect the existing metal roof and decking underneath to assess the condition of the structure. They check for water damage, rot, or weakened areas that need repair.
Step 2: Removal of Metal Roof
The contractor carefully removes all metal panels and fasteners. Depending on the installation, some panels may overlap, requiring special tools for detachment. The old underlayment is also removed if it’s not compatible with shingles.
Step 3: Roof Deck Repair
If sections of decking are damaged, they are replaced with plywood or OSB (oriented strand board). The roof must be smooth and secure before installing shingles.
Step 4: Installation of Underlayment
A water-resistant underlayment (roofing felt or synthetic) is installed across the deck. Ice and water shields may be added in valleys and near edges to prevent leaks.
Step 5: Flashing and Drip Edge Setup
New flashing is installed around valleys, chimneys, and roof penetrations. A drip edge is attached to roof edges to guide water away and protect the decking.
Step 6: Asphalt Shingle Installation
Contractors begin laying shingles from the bottom edge upward, following proper stagger patterns for durability and water resistance. Nails secure the shingles according to manufacturer recommendations.
Step 7: Ventilation Adjustments
Ridge vents, soffit vents, or gable vents may be installed or upgraded to ensure proper airflow in the attic, reducing heat buildup and preventing moisture issues.
Step 8: Final Inspection
After installation, the contractor inspects the entire system for proper alignment, sealing, and structural integrity before declaring the project complete.
Cost of Transitioning from Metal to Asphalt Shingles
The cost of switching from metal to asphalt shingles depends on several factors, including the roof size, pitch, decking condition, and the type of shingles chosen. On average:
-
Metal roof removal: $1 to $3 per square foot
-
Decking repairs (if needed): $1.50 to $3.00 per square foot
-
Asphalt shingle installation: $4.50 to $8.50 per square foot
Altogether, most homeowners can expect to pay $7,000 to $18,000 for a typical residential roof replacement, depending on complexity and location.
Pros and Cons of Asphalt Shingles Compared to Metal Roofing
Advantages of Asphalt Shingles
-
Lower upfront cost
-
Easier repairs and replacements
-
Wide variety of colors and styles
-
Quieter during storms
-
Familiar appearance in most neighborhoods
Disadvantages Compared to Metal
-
Shorter lifespan (15–30 years vs. 40–70 years for metal)
-
More vulnerable to wind, hail, and fire damage
-
Can trap heat in hot climates
-
Requires more frequent maintenance
Key Considerations Before Making the Switch
-
Longevity vs. Cost – Are you looking for a long-term roofing solution or the most affordable option today?
-
Neighborhood Aesthetics – Will shingles better match nearby homes, or do you prefer the unique style of metal?
-
Future Home Sale – Asphalt shingles may appeal to more buyers, but metal roofing can increase home value in some markets.
-
Climate – Metal is more resilient in extreme conditions, while shingles may suffice in milder regions.
-
Structural Support – Ensure your roof deck and trusses can handle the additional weight of asphalt shingles.
Conclusion
Transitioning from a metal roof to asphalt shingles is a major project that requires careful planning, skilled labor, and consideration of both short-term and long-term needs. While metal roofing remains the gold standard for durability, asphalt shingles continue to dominate the roofing industry due to affordability, versatility, and ease of installation.
For homeowners prioritizing budget, aesthetics, and practicality, switching to shingles can be a smart move. However, it’s important to weigh the reduced lifespan and higher maintenance against the immediate savings and improved curb appeal. Consulting with an experienced roofing contractor will help ensure a smooth, safe, and cost-effective transition.